The History of Surgery in World War I: A Correspondence between Fedor Krause (1857 – 1937) and Arthur Simons (1877 – 1942)

Document Type : Original Article

Author

M.D., Responsible physician, Gartenweg 24, Wanzleben Saxony-Anhalt, Germany

Abstract

This study focuses on a correspondence between the surgeon, Fedor Krause (1857 – 1937), and the neurologist, Arthur Simons (1877 – 1942), who specialized in muscle neurology. The correspondence shows many interesting aspects of surgery at the time of World War I. It is especially remarkable that the important surgeon, August Bier (1861 – 1949), is criticized in this correspondence. One major problem of German surgery at the beginning of the 20th century was the fact that patients often were not mobilized sufficiently and instead, unnecessarily were told to stay in bed (“Bettruhe”) for many weeks, and in many cases, patients also were unnecessarily told to move as little as possible. Even giving massages was considered harmful. This is in contrast to today’s principle of early mobility (ERAS). The correspondence between these two scholars clearly indicates that these wrong principles were propagated by certain important surgeons in Germany (like August Bier) and that these principles were rather based on their personal opinions than on scientific evidence. More than 100 years ago, there were already some physicians, like Arthur Simons or Fedor Krause, who openly criticized these wrong approaches in German surgery. 

Keywords

References

  1. Bier, A., 1899. Versuche über die Cocainisierung des Rückenmarks. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Chirurgie, 51, pp. 361-368.
  2. Bier, A., 1903. Hyperämie als Heilmittel. Leipzig: Vogel.
  3. Bier, A., 1917. Beobachtung über Regeneration beim Menschen. II. Abhandlung: Die Ursachen der Regeneration. 1. Bedeutung der Schädigung. Die Erhaltung der Lücke. 2. Reize. Körpereigene Reize. Fourth sub – part, second part of a series. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift, 43(30), pp. 925-928 (especially p. 926).
  4. Biwald, B., 2000. Von Helden und Krüppeln. Das österreichisch-ungarische Militärsanitätswesen und dessen Auswirkungen auf die Gesellschaft im Ersten Weltkrieg. Dissertation (Doctoral Thesis). Vienna University, Vienna.
  5. Callaghan, M.J. and Oldham, J.A., 2004. Quadriceps atrophy: to what extent does it exist in patellofemoral pain syndrome? British Journal of Sports Medicine, 38(3), pp. 295-299.
  6. Eiselsberg, A.V., 1937. Lebensweg eines Chirurgen. Innsbruck: Deutscher Alpenverlag Ges. M. B. H.
  7. Enzensberger, A., 2021. Übergangsräume – Deutsche Lazarette im Ersten Weltkrieg. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
  8. Haas, L.F., 2002. Harvey Williams Cushing (1869–1939). Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 73, p. 596.
  9. Harden, R.N. et al., 2006. Treatment of Complex Regional Pain Syndrome: Functional Restauration. Clinical Journal of Pain, 5, pp. 420-424.
  10. Harden, R.N. et al., 2010. Validation of proposed diagnostic criteria (the “Budapest Criteria”) for Complex Regional Pain Syndrome. Pain, 150 (2), pp. 268-274.
  11. Holdorff, B., 2012. Arthur Simons über tonische Halsreflexe beim Hemiplegiker. Der Nervenarzt, 83, pp. 514-519.
  12. Holdorff, B., 2015. Arthur Simons (1877 – 1942) and Tonic Neck Reflexes with Hemiplegic “Mitbewegungen” (Associated Reactions): Cinematography from 1916 – 1919. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences, 25, pp. 63-71.
  13. Hsu, C., Harden, R.N., and Houle, T., 2002. Nicotine and caffeine intake in complex regional pain syndrome. Journal of back and musculoskeletal rehabilitation, 16(1), pp. 33-38.
  14. Kehlet, H., and Mogensen, T., 1999. Hospital stay of 2 days after open sigmoidectomy with a multimodal rehabilitation programme. British Journal of Surgery, 86, pp. 227-230.
  15. Klee, E., 2005. Das Personenlexikon zum Dritten Reich. Wer war was vor und nach 1945. 2nd ed. Frankfurt on Main: Fischer Taschenbuch.
  16. Krause, F., 1887. Über Maligne Neurome und das Vorkommen von Nervenfasern in denselben. Habilitation (postdoctoral lecture qualification). Medicinische Fakultät der vereinigten Friedrichs – Universität Halle – Wittenberg. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel.
  17. Kuhlendahl, H., 1973. Anfänge der Neurochirurgie in Deutschland: Fedor Krause. Zeitschrift für Neurologie, 204, pp. 159-163.
  18. Lessing, T.D.L., 1929. Prager Tagblatt. Prague Daily Newspaper, 23 March. p. 4.
  19. Lotz, G.W., 1978. Der Chirurg Victor Schmieden (1874 – 1945): sein Leben u. seine Beiträge zur operativen Versorgung perforierender Bauchschüsse im Kriege, zur Chirurgie des Herzbeutels und zur Therapie der akuten Pankreasnekrose. Dissertation (Doctoral Thesis). Frankfurt on Main University, Frankfurt on Main.
  20. Müller, M., 1955. Bier, August. In: Neue Deutsche Biographie 2, pp. 230–231. Available at: https://www.deutsche-biographie.de/pnd118658816.html#ndbcontent [Accessed 7 July 2022]
  21. Reggiani, A.H., 2007. God’s Eugenicist: Alexis Carrel and the Sociobiology of Decline. New York: Berghahn Books.
  22. Rehor, T., 2011. Mörser und Pastillen, Die k. u. k. Militärpharmazie im Ersten Weltkrieg. Wien: Österreichische Apotheker, Verlag, Gesellschaft.
  23. Reichmann, J.C., 2009. Tapfere Askers “und Feige Araber”, Der osmanische Verbündete aus der Sicht deutscher Soldaten im Orient 1914-1918. Dissertation (Doctoral Thesis). Münster University, Philosophical Faculty, Münster.
  24. Röttgen, P., 1983. Neurochirurgie. In: Schreiber, H.W. and Carstensen, G. eds. 1983. Chirurgie im Wandel der Zeit 1945 – 1983. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 148-155.
  25. Sachs, M. and Encke, A., 1997. Victor Schmieden (1874 – 1945) and his contribution to the development of modern surgery. Zentralblatt für Chirurgie, 122, pp. 597-609.
  26. Shibuya, N. et al., 2013. Efficacy and safety of high-dose vitamin C on complex regional pain syndrome in extremity trauma and surgery – systematic review and meta – analysis. Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery, 52 (1), pp. 62-66.
  27. Simons, A., 1917. Knochen und Nerv (Kriegserfahrungen). Zeitschrift für die gesamte Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 37, pp. 36-63.
  28. Stürzbecher, M., 1980. Krause, Fedor. In: Neue Deutsche Biographe, 12, p. 700. Available at: https://www.deutsche-biographie.de/pnd118715690.html#ndbcontent [Accessed 7 July 2022]
  29. The Battle of Verdun (1914 – 1918), 1919. Published by Michelin & Cie. France: Clermont – Ferrand.
  30. Uzbekova, D.G. , 2014. V. P. Kravkov as a sanitary physician of the Russian Imperial Army
  31. (to centenary of beginning of the First World War). Problemy sotsial’noi gigieny, zdravookhraneniia I istorii meditsiny, 4, pp. 51-54.
  32. Vogeler, K., 1941. August Bier – Leben und Werk. München Berlin: J. F. Lehmanns.
  33. Winter, J.M., 1985. The Great War and the British People. London: Macmillan.

 

Journal of Research on History of Medicine
Volume 11, Issue 4
November 2022
Pages 233-244

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics